8 Old Navy Scarves, Hats, and Gloves to Keep You Warm This Fall

Updated on 10/16/2023 at 10:15 AM

Old Navy

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

No matter how organized and careful you are, it may seem impossible to get through a whole season without at least one item growing feet and walking away. Whether it's a solitary glove, a hat strategically stashed who-knows-where, or a scarf nonchalantly shed once and never recovered, nobody wants to be left frustrated on a blustery day. With that in mind, we combed through Old Navy's inventory to find the best budget-friendly scarves, hats, and gloves that'll keep you warm this fall.

We rounded up the best of the best. You can find a pair of convertible mittens that can either cover your fingers or allow them to breathe, a snug poncho ideal for draping over your computer desk when you need warmth, and a Fair Isle-patterned scarf that evokes the cozy charm of your favorite fall sweater, and much more. One thing's for sure: you have plenty of options when it comes to complementing your fall wardrobe. Keep scrolling to shop our eight favorite hats, gloves, and scarves from Old Navy for fall 2023, starting at $10.

Best Mittens

Old Navy Convertible Sherpa-Trim Mittens ($10, originally $17)

These mittens are convertible, allowing you to either fully cover your hands or expose your fingers when it's too warm. Select from two available colors: brown and beige.

Old Navy Convertible Sherpa-Trim Mittens

From

$10

$17 Now 41% off

Best Scarf

Old Navy Brushed Scarf ($20)

This scarf comes in several different colorways and features fun fringe edges. It's highly rated, too, with a near-perfect five-star rating. "This thing is amazing," wrote a pleased reviewer. "Bought it on a whim and SO GLAD I did. Super soft and warm. Also neutral enough that I can pair it with ANYTHING."

Old Navy Brushed Scarf

From

$20

Best Beanie

Old Navy Gender Neutral Wide Cuff Beanie Hat ($10, originally $13)

Chances are you'll want this beanie in more than one color. It comes in both neutrals and bolder pops of color, and shoppers say it's soft and stretchy.

Old Navy Gender Neutral Wide Cuff Beanie Hat

From

$10

$13 Now 23% off

Best Rib-Knit Scarf

Old Navy Rib-Knit Scarf ($20)

Fresh from the brand's new arrivals section, this rib-knit scarf features a cozy, ribbed-knit design. We love how many bright colors it comes in, including the green one pictured here, as well as royal blue and hot pink, among others.

Old Navy Rib-Knit Scarf

From

$20

Best Cable-Knit Hat

Old Navy Wide Cuff Beanie Hat ($10, originally $15)

Prefer your beanie to have a bit more texture? Take a look at this cable-knit-patterned style, complete with a wide brim with rib-knit detailing.

Old Navy Wide Cuff Beanie Hat

From

$10

$15 Now 33% off

Best Flannel Scarf

Plaid Flannel Scarf ($20)

This brushed flannel scarf has over 1,500 five-star ratings from shoppers. It comes in several flannel colorways, including perfect-for-fall options like this brown plaid design and a predominantly monochrome pink style with pops of red.

Plaid Flannel Scarf

From

$20

Best Poncho

Old Navy Flannel Poncho ($30)

An Old Navy shopper brilliantly labeled this poncho "THE gift for the holiday season," writing: "Who doesn't freeze in the office or want to cuddle up during a good streaming binge?? This soft, cozy shawl is the answer." It comes in multiple colorways and boasts a stylish hi-low hem.

Old Navy Flannel Poncho

From

$30

Best Fair Isle Scarf

Old Navy Fair Isle Scarf ($20)

Whether you pair this scarf with your favorite Fair Isle sweater or wear it as a standalone accessory, we're confident you'll discover countless ways to style it. The texture is reminiscent of a cozy blanket, a testament to how frequently you'll want to wrap yourself up in its warmth.

Old Navy Fair Isle Scarf

From

$20